E-Newsletter Sign Up!

Make Us Your Homepage

Housing crisis continues
Developer abandons trailer project, city rejects apartment loan

By Nick Smith
Staff Writer
Published/Last Modified on Friday, October 30, 2009 10:30 AM CDT



Alan Reed|Williston Herald A road closed sign continues to sit at one of the entrances to the former Cimarron Heights trailer park in northwest Williston. Colorado developers are no longer going to pursue placing trailers at the facility due to financing issues.
Housing needs in Williston took another serious hit this week as the Williston City Commission was informed that a developer who intended to put units in the Cimarron Heights trailer court pulled the plug on the project.

During its regular monthly meeting Tuesday evening, the commission also rejected the terms a developer requested for a loan on apartments he's planning to build in Williston.

The late pull-out of the proposed development of Cimarron Heights is by Paul Clift and Mike Hoffman of Breckinridge, Colo.

"The developer for Cimarron Heights has informed us that due to a financing issue, the deal has fallen apart," said Mayor Ward Koeser.

Clift and Hoffman had received approval of their bid for developing the trailer court into a single-family mobile home community. Their goal had been to begin developing a portion of the court before the end of the year, with the long-term goal of bringing the park up to capacity at 312 units. At a Sept. 29 special meeting, they reached an agreement on terms, which said they had to close on financing by Oct. 25 and have the first trailers on lots by Dec. 18.

Koeser said it is disappointing to see another possible deal on Cimarron Heights fall through.

He said despite the housing situation being critical in Williston for some time, it seems as though banks are very reluctant to give loans in the tough national economy.

Koeser added there had been some discussion in an ad-hoc meeting about a short-term way to deal with relieving a small amount of pressure on local housing demand.

"We spoke about opening up part of the trailer court for the winter," said Koeser.

Koeser said it's an idea they don't really like because "the city doesn't like to get into the business of operating a trailer court, nor should it."

The plan would be to contract someone to dig up and upgrade utility lines for up to 20 units at the court and allow people to stay there short term over the winter, likely for about six months.

"It's really iffy, but there's a willingness to try. So it depends on the weather and the ability to find someone to do the digging up," said Koeser.

City auditor John Kautzman said there had been some initial conversations with a local trailer court operator, but it wasn't set in stone if there was a desire to move forward and such an agreement would need to be in writing.

"I think we just authorize it to see if it's possible, but if it isn't, it isn't," said Commissioner Brad Bekkedahl.

A motion to authorize looking into the possibility of getting up to 20 units running in the next few weeks passed unanimously, with Commissioner Brent Bogar not in attendance.

The second issue discussed Tuesday was rejected after a conference call and discussion. Discussion involved terms of a loan proposed by George Gaukler of Valley Realty Inc. of Valley City for two 36-plex apartment buildings he's trying to build.

The proposal was for a $300,000 loan at zero percent interest for three years.

Koeser asked Gaukler if he received approval from them and from a bank, would he be be able to get started before the end of the year and have units ready by the end of next summer. Gaukler replied he could.

Bekkedahl questioned the lack of loans being approved, as well as the terms of the loan itself.

He said it is a shame all of this federal bailout money was given to banks nationwide and then few loans are being approved.

"Our taxpayers are going to be wondering about these terms such as zero percent interest if we approve and ask why are we doing this," said Bekkedahl.

A member of the audience, Tanya Vachal of Job Service North Dakota in Williston, questioned the issue of not only housing, but the affordability of it.

"There are people who don't have oil field money, and we have to deal with that," said Vachal.

She added if the cost of housing isn't brought down, it's going to drive people and businesses away.

Koeser said the city faces a unique situation where demand is high, there are extremely high rates on things such as electric work on projects, and banks are reluctant to give out loans.

"The only way people are going to get to the place where we see prices go down is when we have the adequate amount of housing to meet demand. Unfortunately we're not even close to that, and I think the only way we're going to see that happen is when we have enough housing where at some point the older complexes are able to bring prices down," said Koeser.

Economic Development director Tom Rolfstad told commissioners before the vote he thought at this point any housing would be a plus. He recently spoken to officials at Halliburton, who may possibly be hiring up to 120 more workers, further increasing the housing crisis

Rolfstad also asked if it might be appropriate to send a letter to the state's congressional delegation in Washington regarding the city's situation to see if they may be able to assist in any way. The commission gave permission to draft a letter.

After further discussion, the commission voted to reject the Gaukler proposal in its current form. The vote was a tie, with Bekkedahl and Koeser voting in favor and commissioners Howard Klug and James Lawson voting against it.
 

Comments

    Frank wrote on Nov 8, 2009 9:04 PM:

    " No more fast food please. Williston's pants are already big enough. "

    Bill Brasky wrote on Nov 4, 2009 9:48 AM:

    " I moved here last year, not oilfield related, and was completely shocked at how the common person is getting ripped of in Williston. The only available living situations were overpriced homes, 1100/month apts, or 1500/month trailers in a shanty town. I honestly don't know how anyone making under $15/hour could afford to live as we aren't putting anything away while pulling in a combined approx. $37/hr.

    After 6 months of searching, I found a decently priced home, talk about the worst time of my life. GF/Fargo/BisMan offer much nicer townhomes/apts for under half the price! Greed, greed, greed. Oh yeah, and if you go shopping in another town for groceries, you'll also realize you get the shaft there too. "

    t wrote on Nov 2, 2009 2:49 AM:

    " Any time we're in need of housing around Williston or surrounding areas theres one problem...
    It's not AFFORDABLE housing. All these new homes are put up asking for sooo much money & there's no decent apartments or housing for people who aren't working on thr rigs or financially high up. It's forcing people away & it's sad & quite tiring. "

    Carol wrote on Oct 31, 2009 7:07 PM:

    " I think in this case, the city maybe should get into the business for the short term. At least get part of the park up and running, and then sell it to any interested parties down the road when the loan issues get better. It is better to have a city run court than none at all. If no local trailer park owner is interested, and do not want to work with the city on it. Then the city should just do it. "

    Kathy wrote on Oct 30, 2009 4:43 PM:

    " The comment regarding the over priced rent is right on, how can someone making $8.00 an hour make rent of $900.00 and up? Williston desperatley needs affordable, safe and adequate housing and soon. I also agree with the comment made regarding more fast food or for that matter just resturants and maybe a small strip mall, something to draw the people moving here to stay and make it their home. "

    funfun wrote on Oct 30, 2009 2:06 PM:

    " Probably because they can turn huge profits by jacking prices sky high on the existing homes they build and selling them to people with oilfield money. Less work, manpower, and money means they can profit more on 1 home than they would on 10 in Bismarck or Fargo. I have seen it, newly built homes in Fargo can be had for under 150,000 while the same here is about 300,000. "

    WhyWillistonGetsIgnored wrote on Oct 30, 2009 11:27 AM:

    " I'm just curious how these developers in Bismarck and Fargo get all their money to put up hundreds of homes at a time for $160,00...and we can't get any of these developers to come into Williston? Has anyone contacted developers in the larger communities? Just curious. I'm also confused why there are no new fast food places being built in this town to take care fo this need. "

Write a Comment

Comment posters are responsible for the opinions they express and the accuracy of the information they provide. We urge comment writers to treat this as a public forum where manners matter. We encourage a collegial, non-insulting tone. All readers comments must be approved by our staff before posting to the Web site. Be aware, in accordance with the Communications Decency Act and provisions upheld in judicial appeal, that you are responsible for comments posted on this Web site. The Williston Herald is not liable for messages from third parties.

DO NOT POST:
* Potentially libelous statements or damaging innuendo.
* Obscene, explicit, or racist language.
* Personal attacks, insults or threats.
* The use of another person's real name to disguise your identity.
* Comments unrelated to the story.

Opinions, advice and all other information expressed in WillistonHerald.com's reader comments represent the individual's own views and not necessarily those of the Williston Herald. The Williston Herald does not endorse and is not responsible for statements, advice or opinions offered by anyone other than authorized Williston Herald spokespersons.

Thank you for your comments!

(optional)
   

Contact Us

Mailing Address:
Williston Herald
P.O. Box 1447
Williston, ND
58802

Street Address:
14 W. 4th St.
Williston, ND 58801

Phone:
701-572-2165

Fax:
701-572-9563

Inside North Dakota:
1-800-950-2165

Classifieds

Shopping